Carentan Speak on it...
Posted 12 January 2003 - 01:21 AM
I love the Malarkey scene-it makes me cry every time. I think it really brings it home how costly it was.
Posted 12 January 2003 - 05:03 PM
I had no idea that the real Blithe was from Philly, it's a wonder that Guarnere or Heffron didn't know him huh? Seems like those guys could sniff each other out.
I can tell you from personal experience that I served with more than a few Blithe's in the service and I don't think I'm alone. Also, there may have been two Blithe's in the 506th. The first Blithe that performed ably enough because it was training, and the latter Blithe who's performance was questionable once under fire.
Posted 12 January 2003 - 05:09 PM
My personal favorite was the narrative of Lipton as he's writing in the company log(or diary?), sitting in a church lit by candles, choir in the background, and we see the casualties disappear from the pews in front of our eyes. That scene was one of the most poignant to me.
Posted 14 January 2003 - 12:22 AM
Just a thought - the scene in Carentan where Winters and Nixon exchange looks after being asked whether it was safe to cross the road - Winters gets hit by a ricochet only a few seconds later. I felt this was a small reminder that this was a war zone, and nowhere was really safe. Winters reacts with almost disgust to getting hit - yes it hurts, but he has just assured someone else that it was safe, and now he has been wounded standing in exactly the same spot only seconds later.
Posted 14 January 2003 - 08:34 AM
It probably happened, and it's probably unfair to Strayer, but it's still a good scene.
Posted 14 January 2003 - 12:28 PM
We were informed on the BoB tour that the Winters-Strayers exchange did happen, and that it happened right outside the arched collonnade depicted there (great bit of detail), which we also visited in Carentan, but that Nix was not present at the time.
My sense of Winters' reaction was not that he was angry at himself. He certainly was not in the business of guaranteeing safety to anyone in a combat zone, not his C.O, and not himself. I thought he was simply angry that it hurt, as when you stub your toe, and that it was gonna get in the way of doing his job. "I haven't got time for this." In fact, I thought Winters' reaction was quite novel as a take on being wounded; whether that was an acting or directing choice, it was well done.
My thunks. y.o.s., Doug
Posted 06 February 2003 - 08:11 AM
Ok, I was wathing Carentan again last night...and I have some questions..
1. I know I recognize this guy--but who is --and where have I seen him before--the actor who asks Welsh where they're headed--right around when Hoobler says he'll lead...and when Welsh tells our boy Luz not be playing "grab fanny" with anyone... I know this guy from somewhere.
2. What does More ask Spiers when Spiers tell them to not get comfortable b/c we're moving out.. not the part when he asks, "don't they know we're just getting settled here.." or something like that--but before that.. (I think More has been lurking about my foxhole...I think I might offer him an invitation while I loan out Lipton... :D )
Have a good one!
Posted 06 February 2003 - 08:32 AM
I'm not sure if this is what you're asking but here's a little of that scene:
Speirs: Enjoy it while it lasts. Weíll be moviní out soon
More: Out of town Lt.? Already?
Speirs: Thatís right
More: Donít they know weíre just getting settled here?
Muck: Nice groucho!
Muck: Real smart. You know youíre taking your life in your own hands. Ainít that right?
Hope that helps...
Guess who wants to loan Lipton?
Posted 06 February 2003 - 02:35 PM
marigold, on Jan 15 2003, 03:54 AM, said:
Bob Strayer died last year, so he lived long enough to attend Easy Company reunions and see the book...
I wonder what he thought of that particular scene?
I'd also like to know what Bob Strayer might have had to say about Captain Sobel's relief and Lt. Jones's promotions.
Posted 06 February 2003 - 11:00 PM